Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1978

An Act to regulate the admission of certain evidence in proceedings relating to sexual offences and the mode of taking evidence in such proceedings, to protect persons concerned in the commission of sexual offences from identification, and for related purposes

pt 1 hdg ins 2003 No. 55 s 37

1Short title

This Act may be cited as the Criminal Law (Sexual Offences) Act 1978.

3Definitions

In this Act—

complainant means a person in respect of whom a sexual offence is alleged to have been committed.

s 3 def complainant sub 1989 No. 17 s 83 (a)

amd 2000 No. 43 s 37 (2)

defendant means a person charged with having committed a sexual offence.

examination of witnesses means an examination of witnesses in relation to an indictable offence, being a sexual offence, commenced after the commencement of this Act and taken pursuant to the Justices Act 1886.

executive officer, of a corporation, means a person who is concerned with, or takes part in, the corporation’s management, whether or not the person is a director or the person’s position is given the name of executive officer.

s 3 def executive officer ins 2013 No. 51 s 22

Minister ...

s 3 def Minister ins 1990 No. 80 s 3 sch 1

om R1 (see RA s 39)

prescribed sexual offence means any of the following offences—

(a)rape;

(b)attempt to commit rape;

(c)assault with intent to commit rape;

(d)an offence defined in the Criminal Code, section 352.

s 3 def prescribed sexual offence ins 1989 No. 17 s 83 (b)

amd 1990 No. 93 s 15

sub 1997 No. 3 s 122 sch 2

amd 2000 No. 43 s 37 (3)

report means an account in writing and an account broadcast or distributed in any way in or as sound or visual images.

s 3 def report sub 1997 No. 3 s 122 sch 2

sexual offence means any offence of a sexual nature, and includes a prescribed sexual offence.

s 3 def sexual offence sub 1989 No. 17 s 83 (c)

the court includes justices taking an examination of witnesses.

trial means a trial of a defendant and a proceeding taken with a view to sentencing a defendant convicted of a sexual offence, which in either case is commenced after the commencement of this Act.

s 3 sub 2000 No. 43 s 37 (1)

pt 2 hdg ins 2003 No. 55 s 38

4Special rules limiting particular evidence about sexual offences

The following rules shall apply in relation to any examination of witnesses or trial in relation to a sexual offence whether or not the examination or trial relates also to a charge of an offence other than a sexual offence against the same or any other defendant—

1The court shall not receive evidence of and shall disallow any question as to the general reputation of the complainant with respect to chastity.

2Without leave of the court—

(a)cross-examination of the complainant shall not be permitted as to the sexual activities of the complainant with any person; and

(b)evidence shall not be received as to the sexual activities of the complainant with any person.

3The court shall not grant leave under rule 2 unless it is satisfied that the evidence sought to be elicited or led has substantial relevance to the facts in issue or is proper matter for cross-examination as to credit.

4Evidence relating to or tending to establish the fact that the complainant has engaged in sexual activity with a person or persons must not be regarded as having substantial relevance to the facts in issue only because of any inference it may raise about general disposition.

Example of inference about general disposition—

an inference that the complainant, because of having engaged in conduct of a sexual nature, is more likely to have consented to the conduct involved in the offence

Without prejudice to the substantial relevance of other evidence, evidence of an act or event that is substantially contemporaneous with any offence with which a defendant is charged in an examination of witnesses or a trial or that is part of a sequence of acts or events that explains the circumstances in which such an offence was committed shall be regarded as having substantial relevance to the facts in issue.

5Evidence relating to or tending to establish the fact that the complainant has engaged in sexual activity with a person or persons is not proper matter for cross-examination as to credit unless, because of special circumstances, the court considers the evidence would be likely to materially impair confidence in the reliability of the complainant’s evidence.

The purpose of this rule is to ensure that a complainant is not regarded as less worthy of belief as a witness only because the complainant has engaged in sexual activity.

6An application for leave under rule 2 shall be made in the absence of the jury (if any) and, if the defendant so requests, in the absence of the complainant and shall be determined after the court has allowed such submissions or evidence (sworn or unsworn) as the court considers necessary for the determination of the application.

s 4 amd 1989 No. 17 s 84; 2000 No. 43 s 38; 2003 No. 55 s 39

4AEvidence of complaint generally admissible

(1)This section applies in relation to an examination of witnesses, or a trial, in relation to a sexual offence.

(2)Evidence of how and when any preliminary complaint was made by the complainant about the alleged commission of the offence by the defendant is admissible in evidence, regardless of when the preliminary complaint was made.

(3)Nothing in subsection (2) derogates from the power of the court in a criminal proceeding to exclude evidence if the court is satisfied it would be unfair to the defendant to admit the evidence.

(4)If a defendant is tried by a jury, the judge must not warn or suggest in any way to the jury that the law regards the complainant’s evidence to be more reliable or less reliable only because of the length of time before the complainant made a preliminary or other complaint.

(5)Subject to subsection (4), the judge may make any comment to a jury on the complainant’s evidence that it is appropriate to make in the interests of justice.

Note—

See also the Criminal Code, section 632 and the Evidence Act 1977, section 132BA.

(6)In this section—

complaint includes a disclosure.

preliminary complaint means any complaint other than—

(a)the complainant’s first formal witness statement to a police officer given in, or in anticipation of, a criminal proceeding in relation to the alleged offence; or

(b)a complaint made after the complaint mentioned in paragraph (a).

Example—

Soon after the alleged commission of a sexual offence, the complainant discloses the alleged commission of the offence to a parent (complaint 1). Many years later, the complainant makes a complaint to a secondary school teacher and a school guidance officer (complaints 2 and 3). The complainant visits the local police station and makes a complaint to the police officer at the front desk (complaint 4). The complainant subsequently attends an appointment with a police officer and gives a formal witness statement to the police officer in anticipation of a criminal proceeding in relation to the alleged offence (complaint 5). After a criminal proceeding is begun, the complainant gives a further formal witness statement (complaint 6).

Each of complaints 1 to 4 is a preliminary complaint. Complaints 5 and 6 are not preliminary complaints.

s 4A ins 2003 No. 55 s 40

amd 2020 No. 32 s 30

pt 3 hdg ins 2003 No. 55 s 41

5Exclusion of public

(1)Whilst a complainant is giving evidence in any examination of witnesses or trial, the court shall cause to be excluded from the room in which it is then sitting all persons other than the following—

(a)the counsel and solicitor of the complainant;

(b)the defendant and the defendant’s counsel and solicitor;

(c)a Crown law officer or a person authorised by a Crown law officer;

(d)the prosecutor;

(e)any person whose presence is, in the opinion of the court, necessary or desirable for the proper conduct of the examination or trial;

(f)any person whose presence will provide emotional support to the complainant;

(g)where the complainant is under or apparently under the age of 17 years—the parent or guardian of the child unless, in the court’s opinion, the presence of that person would not be in the child’s interests;

(h)any person who makes application to the court to be present and whose presence, in the court’s opinion—

(i)would serve a proper interest of the applicant; and

(ii)would not be prejudicial to the interests of the complainant.

(2)The provisions of subsection (1) shall be construed so as not to prejudice the power of the court had under any other provision or rule of law to exclude from the room in which it is sitting any person, including a defendant.

s 5 amd 1987 No. 32 s 69 (1) sch

sub 1989 No. 17 s 85

6Publication at large of complainant’s identity prohibited

(1)Any report made or published concerning an examination of witnesses or a trial, other than a report specified in section 8(1), shall not reveal the name, address, school or place of employment of a complainant therein or any other particular likely to lead to the identification of a complainant therein unless the court, for good and sufficient reason shown, orders to the contrary.

(2)If the court makes an order to the contrary it may therein specify—

(a)the particulars that may be revealed; and

(b)the extent to which publication of the report made is permitted.

(3)A person must not make or publish a report that contravenes subsection (1).

Maximum penalty—

(a)for an individual—100 penalty units or 2 years imprisonment; or

(b)for a corporation—1,000 penalty units.

Note—

If a corporation commits an offence against this provision, an executive officer of the corporation may be taken, under section 12, to have also committed the offence.

(4)If the court makes an order under subsection (2) about the making or publishing of a report, a person who makes or publishes a report that contravenes the order commits an offence.

Maximum penalty—

(a)for an individual—100 penalty units or 2 years imprisonment; or

(b)for a corporation—1,000 penalty units.

Note—

If a corporation commits an offence against this provision, an executive officer of the corporation may be taken, under section 12, to have also committed the offence.

(5)The fact that a person is liable to a penalty for an offence under subsection (4) does not prevent the person being dealt with for contempt of court evidenced by the person’s offence.

s 6 amd 2008 No. 55 s 129; 2013 No. 51 s 229 sch 1

7Publication prematurely of defendant’s identity prohibited

(1)Any report made or published concerning an examination of witnesses in relation to a prescribed sexual offence, other than a report specified in section 8, shall not reveal the name, address, school or place of employment of a defendant therein or any other particular likely to lead to identification of a defendant therein unless the justices taking the examination, for good and sufficient reason shown, order to the contrary.

(2)If justices make an order to the contrary they may therein specify—

(a)the particulars that may be revealed; and

(b)the extent to which publication of the report made is permitted.

(3)A person must not make or publish a report that contravenes subsection (1).

Maximum penalty—

(a)for an individual—100 penalty units or 2 years imprisonment; or

(b)for a corporation—1,000 penalty units.

Note—

If a corporation commits an offence against this provision, an executive officer of the corporation may be taken, under section 12, to have also committed the offence.

(4)If justices makes an order under subsection (2) about the making or publishing of a report, a person who makes or publishes a report that contravenes the order commits an offence.

Maximum penalty—

(a)for an individual—100 penalty units or 2 years imprisonment; or

(b)for a corporation—1,000 penalty units.

Note—

If a corporation commits an offence against this provision, an executive officer of the corporation may be taken, under section 12, to have also committed the offence.

(5)The fact that a person is liable to a penalty for an offence under subsection (4) does not prevent the person being dealt with for contempt of court evidenced by the person’s offence.

s 7 amd 1989 No. 17 s 86; 2008 No. 55 s 130; 2013 No. 51 s 229 sch 1

8Exempted reports

(1)Sections 6 and 7 do not apply to—

(a)a report made for the purposes of an examination of witnesses or a trial or of a proceeding on appeal arising from a trial; or

(b)a report made verbatim of a judgment or decision delivered in a trial or in a proceeding on appeal arising from a trial and contained in a recognised series of law reports; or

(c)a report made to or on behalf of the Department of Justice and Attorney-General, the commissioner of the police service, the Queensland College of Teachers or the department for the time being administering the Child Protection Act 1999 for the purposes of the department or other entity to or on behalf of which it is made; or

(d)a report made to or on behalf of a relevant education entity for the purposes of the entity to or on behalf of which it is made, if the report relates to a defendant mentioned in column 1, item 5(1) or 7A of the table in the Criminal Law (Rehabilitation of Offenders) Act 1986, section 9A; or

(e)a report made to or on behalf of the Crime and Corruption Commission.

(2)Section 7 does not apply to a report made concerning an examination of witnesses that reveals any particular referred to in that section of a defendant therein who as a result of the examination is committed for trial or sentence upon a charge of a sexual offence if the report is made after the committal order is made and does not reveal any such particular of any other defendant therein who is not so committed.

(3)In this section—

relevant education entity means—

(a)the department in which the Education (General Provisions) Act 2006 is administered; or

(b)TAFE Queensland established under the TAFE Queensland Act 2013.

s 8 amd 1987 No. 32 s 69 (1) sch; 1997 No. 83 s 8; 1999 No. 10 s 205 sch 3; 2005 No. 47 s 329 sch 2; 2008 No. 55 s 131; 2014 No. 21 s 94 (2) sch 2; 2014 No. 25 s 223 sch 1 pt 2

9Act affords additional protection

Sections 6 and 7 shall be construed to be in addition to and not to prejudice any other provision or rule of law directed towards the protection of witnesses or other persons in an examination of witnesses or a trial from identification.

10When other publication of complainant’s or defendant’s identity is prohibited

(1)A person who, by a statement or representation made or published otherwise than in a report concerning an examination of witnesses or a trial, reveals the name, address, school or place of employment, or any other particular that is likely to lead to the identification, of—

(a)a complainant, at any time; or

(b)a defendant charged with a prescribed sexual offence to which the statement or representation relates, before the defendant is committed for trial or sentence upon that charge;

commits an offence except where the statement or representation is made or published for an authorised purpose referred to in section 11.

Maximum penalty—

(a)for an individual—100 penalty units or 2 years imprisonment; or

(b)for a corporation—1,000 penalty units.

Note—

If a corporation commits an offence against this provision, an executive officer of the corporation may be taken, under section 12, to have also committed the offence.

(2)It is a defence to a proceeding for an offence against subsection (1)(a) for a person to prove that, before the relevant statement or representation was made or published—

(a)the complainant authorised in writing the making or the publishing of the statement or representation; and

(b)when the complainant authorised the making or the publishing of the statement or representation, the complainant—

(i)was at least 18 years; and

(ii)had capacity to give the authorisation.

(3)In this section—

capacity see the Guardianship and Administration Act 2000, schedule 4.

s 10 amd 1989 No. 17 s 87; 2008 No. 55 s 132; 2013 No. 51 s 229 sch 1

10AProvisions do not affect other laws

Sections 6, 7 and 10 are not intended to prevent a person from giving information that is permitted or required to be given under another law.

s 10A ins 2008 No. 55 s 133

11Authorised purposes

(1)For the purposes of section 10 an authorised purpose is one authorised by or pursuant to this section.

(2)The following purposes are authorised by this section—

(a)the purpose of an investigation into the complaint made by or on behalf of a complainant;

(b)the purpose of preparing for or conducting an examination of witnesses or a trial or a proceeding on appeal arising from a trial.

(3)If, before the commencement of an examination of witnesses or a trial, a defendant makes application to a judge of the Supreme Court for a direction pursuant to this subsection and satisfies the judge that—

(a)the direction is required for the purpose of inducing persons to come forward who are likely to be needed as witnesses at the examination or trial; and

(b)the conduct of the applicant’s defence at the examination or trial is likely to be substantially prejudiced if the direction is not given;

the judge shall direct that section 10(1) shall not, by virtue of an accusation that alleges a sexual offence and is specified in the direction, apply in relation to a complainant or defendant specified in the direction.

(4)If a person who has been convicted of a sexual offence and has given notice of appeal to the Court of Appeal against the conviction or notice of an application for leave to so appeal applies to that court or to a judge of the Supreme Court for a direction pursuant to this subsection and satisfies the court or judge that—

(a)the direction is required for the purpose of obtaining evidence in support of the appeal; and

(b)the applicant is likely to suffer substantial injustice if the direction is not given;

the court or judge shall direct that section 10(1) shall not, by virtue of an accusation that alleges a sexual offence and is specified in the direction, apply in relation to a complainant specified in the direction.

s 11 amd 2008 No. 55 s 134

12Executive officer may be taken to have committed offence

(1)If a corporation commits an offence against a deemed executive liability provision, each executive officer of the corporation is taken to have also committed the offence if—

(a)the officer authorised or permitted the corporation’s conduct constituting the offence; or

(b)the officer was, directly or indirectly, knowingly concerned in the corporation’s conduct.

(2)The executive officer may be proceeded against for, and convicted of, the offence against the deemed executive liability provision whether or not the corporation has been proceeded against for, or convicted of, the offence.

(3)This section does not affect either of the following—

(a)the liability of the corporation for the offence against the deemed executive liability provision;

(b)the liability, under the Criminal Code, chapter 2, of any person, whether or not the person is an executive officer of the corporation, for the offence against the deemed executive liability provision.

(4)In this section—

deemed executive liability provision means any of the following provisions—

•section 6(3)

•section 6(4)

•section 7(3)

•section 7(4)

•section 10(1).

s 12 sub 2013 No. 51 s 23

13Proceedings for offences

A proceeding in respect of an offence against this Act shall be taken in a summary way under the Justices Act 1886 upon the complaint of a person authorised in writing in that behalf by the Minister whose signature shall, for this purpose, be judicially noticed.

s 13 amd 1990 No. 80 s 3 sch 1

pt 4 hdg ins 2003 No. 55 s 42

14Transitional provision for Criminal Law Amendment Act 2000

The reference in the definition of prescribed sexual offence in section 3 to a sexual assault defined in the Criminal Code, section 352 is, in relation to an offence that was committed before the commencement of this section, a reference to a sexual assault defined in the Criminal Code, section 337 as in force at any time before the commencement of this section.

s 14 ins 2000 No. 43 s 39

15Transitional provision for Evidence (Protection of Children) Amendment Act 2003

(1)Section 4A only applies in relation to an examination of witnesses, or a trial, in relation to a sexual offence, that starts or continues after the commencement of this section.

(2)Subsection (1) applies even if the sexual offence was committed, or the complaint was made, before the commencement of this section.

s 15 ins 2003 No. 55 s 43

amd 2004 No. 43 s 3 sch